Recently a friend asked me, in response to a recent airline crash where several people survived: “some people are saying ‘God saved those survivors,’ but does that mean that God didn’t rescue the other 150 people?”
In a nutshell, this is a question like many have asked for millennia: “If God is good, then why is there evil & suffering?”
Christianity has offered numerous responses. Most commonly, it is explained (based upon the “fall” in Genesis 3, humankind’s willful disobedience of God’s commands), that the world, including human nature and nature itself, is in a state of disrepair. In short, when stuff goes wrong, it’s our fault (operator error not a “manufacturer’s defect” or “creator error”). God “allows” evil, suffering and natural disasters to occur. And God can intervene; God can work good things out of difficulty(Rom. 8:28).
Still, after the plane crashes, there is difficulty in our thinking. Our first assumption is usually this: death is the worst thing that can happen. As Christians, however, there is something worse than death: disobedience & disbelief. Willful disobedience is the way of human nature – ya don’t have to learn it; you’re born with this fallen nature, this natural instinct to have your way (have you ever had a baby or have you been a baby? Then you know about original sin first hand!)
Yes, hundreds died on that airplane; that’s tragic. Is death the worst thing that happened that day? Well, I wonder if a bigger question is: “How’d those people live? That is, were they believers in God, obedient to God? To die a human death is one thing. To die eternally is the worst. Life is not simply about “living long earthly lives, freed from as much suffering as possible.” Life is about living God’s way. So, “whether living or dying our life belongs to God.”
So, back to my friend’s question: Is it “God’s fault”? Yes & no. Sure, simply everything is connected to God; it’s His fault since He created everything. But I’m playing with words here: “fault” is not right at all. It’s grace. All creation – yes, even the parts I don’t like – are of God’s grace. It’s grace that we get to live at all.
“Why’d those innocent people have to die?” That’s a rather selfish question. No one has an inherent “right to life.” (Wait, wait – don’t go all secular-politics on me… yet. I belief in “right to life” in most cases.) But, hey – what did you or I do to deserve our lives? Did you earn your way into this world? I think life is a gift: first from God, secondly from your mother (sorry dads, ladies first – they work more than we do to give life anyway).
Here’s some comfort to draw to a close, somewhat, this way-too-simple statement on God’s goodness. When it comes to suffering, the Bible teaches that we do not suffer alone(1 Cor. 1:18); God suffers with us(Phil.3:10). This ever-present reality of God – even after the plane goes down – is given to us in person, in God’s own Son, by His suffering, death and resurrection (Matt. 27,28).
So, whenever we learn of tragedy, whenever we ask “why” or “where is God?” or “Why didn’t God do something?” Remember, God did something eternal in the Cross and God is present in your pain. Ultimately, God will work it for good. In fact, in light of so many tragedies and possible crashes in life, we are better able to learn how truly precious life is – how it truly is … a Gift.